Socratic Questioning
Socratic questioning is a way of using questions, listening and summaries so that a patient can examine a conclusion they have drawn and reach a view of their own. The clinician guides the conversation without deciding in advance where it should end.
What you will learn
Respond to your patient’s distress with an accurate reflection before you examine any thought, and ask one open question at a time.
Reconstruct one specific moment with your patient and identify, in their own words, the meaning they gave it.
Summarise what your patient has told you, ask what they make of it, and adapt to the answer they give, including doubt or disagreement.
Who is it for?
Clinicians who want to help patients examine their own conclusions instead of correcting those conclusions for them. It is most relevant if your questions tend to turn into reassurance, debate or a rapid series of questions, in cognitive behavioural therapy or in any approach where a patient’s interpretation matters.
How does it work?
In cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), how a person feels about a moment depends partly on what they take it to mean (Beck, 2011). Socratic questioning uses questions, listening and summaries to help the patient examine that meaning and reach their own view. The course follows Padesky’s model of guided discovery (Padesky, 1993, 2023).
Padesky’s four stages are informational questions the patient can answer, empathic listening, summaries the patient can correct, and synthesising questions that help the patient consider what they have discovered (Padesky, 1993, 2023).
The course also uses the Three Pillars: Experience, Meaning and Possibility. They are a PsychBase teaching aid, not part of Padesky’s model.
You will practise with one patient throughout:
Iris has ADHD, sleeps four to five hours a night and has cut her work to 25 per cent. Last night her five-year-old son Leo spilled juice on her laptop and she screamed at him. He cried and said, “Mamma is always angry.” She held him afterwards and promised to do better, and she has not stopped hearing his words since. She tends to joke about it before anyone else can.
She did shout at Leo, and that fact stays on the table. What the conversation examines is what she has concluded from it.
Course map
Guiding discovery
Changing minds or guiding discovery, the four stages, the Three Pillars, and when to ask directly instead. A theory module.
Listen before you ask
Reflecting distress in the patient’s words, validating without approving, and hearing what sits under a joke.
One question at a time
Questions the patient can answer, asked one at a time, open in both senses, and what to do with the answer.
Reconstruct one moment
Pillar 1, Experience: walking through one specific moment, and telling what happened apart from what it meant.
Find the meaning
Pillar 2, Meaning: the thought in the moment, the patient’s own definition of it, and a fact told apart from a conclusion.
Summarise and synthesise
Pillar 3, Possibility: the evidence on both sides, a summary in the patient’s words, and the synthesising question.
The first two skill modules practise two of the four stages on their own. The last three run the stages together, once in each pillar. The References page at the end lists every source the course cites.
How to practise
Each skill module ends with one thing to try with your patient. You can keep one conversation going across the modules, so the same session carries each new focus. After an attempt, read the feedback, choose one thing to change and try again.
You can also sit in the patient’s chair in the lab, where Kristina, a fictional cognitive therapist, asks the questions. Noticing which of her questions help you think is useful practice too.